Upgrading to a Bigger Brake Booster
For pre-95 Cherokees and (all) Comanches
by
Andreas Ritterbusch
Posted: June 17, 2001
Last Revision: January 29, 2002
This project is to increase braking power on my '89 4.0L non-HO XJ with the old style single-diaphragm power brake booster. (At the end of this write-up are also some images showing the same upgrade on an '84-'86 XJ with the V6 engine). After I went to 33" tires, I noticed that braking power was clearly not adequate anymore. It was OK with my 31" tires, but the braking system had to be in top shape in order to work satisfactorily. The power brake booster is one step to increase braking performance, but doesn't necessarily kill the budget! More expensive upgrades include a rear disc conversion and upgraded front calipers, etc. This article is about the booster only, and only applies to the older XJs, manufactured before '95. Before the introduction of the double-diaphragm brake boosters, the braking power in earlier XJs and (all) MJs was even worse than it is in the newer ones. Often, the older boosters are leaking and therefore causing all kinds of problems. However, there is a way to upgrade an older XJ or MJ to the newer style brake booster and master cylinder. It is not a direct swap, but with a few modifications, the swap can be as close as a direct swap as any other "upgrade". |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
First of all, this swap includes some "severe" work on your brake system, and this should not be attempted without the proper tools and expertise. However, with the right tools and a bit of brake work related experience, this swap is fairly simple. At this point I want to express special thanks to Kevin Marcus (southern CA), who emailed me with great patience all the troubles he had when he attempted this swap. Also, I want to thank Richard Gauthier (southern CA), who was --to my knowledge-- the first who did this swap (I believe with the help of a shop), and I also want to thank Dan Ishum (southern IL), who provided me with some ideas and his 30+ years of experience as a mechanic, and Tim at Precision Rebuilders (St. Clair, MO) for doing this odd rod-swapping procedure. Last, but not least, I want to thank Bill Ansell for information regarding boosters and master cylinder part numbers and Brandon Shehan for providing the '96 booster pictures. As I understand it, XJs came with the single-diaphragm booster from their inception in '84 through '94. For the '95 and '96 model years the bigger double-diaphragm boosters were used, and also --although with a different part number-- all the XJs from '97 and up. The boosters are the same for ABS and non-ABS models (again: with possibly different part numbers, though). The mystery around those '95 and '96 boosters was be solved after all. Matt Homan gave it a shot and succeeded to swap his '96 booster into an earlier XJ without replacing the pedal rods. Some modifications are necessary, though. A full report from Matt is further below. At this point, I would like to express my thanks to Matt Homan for his submission about how he did this swap without the pedal rod swap. Rob Shelley supplied me with some images and a short report on his '94/ABS double-diaphragm booster. I would like to express my thanks to Rob Shelley for the submission of his numerous images and comments on this booster. See for details below. Unfortunately, there is now word on the length of this '94 double diaphragm booster pedal rod. I personally suspect that there is a chance that it might be the same as the '95/'96 boosters (4-7/8" from spacer to center of eye). |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| The power brake boosters in comparison: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Here are the two brake boosters compared. On the
left is the used '97 booster and on the right is a brake booster out of a
junked '87 XJ. Clearly, the '97 is about twice the size of the '87 booster. [ Large image ] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
A top view of the two boosters for better
comparison. This time the '87 booster is on the left and the bigger
double-diaphragm booster out of a '97 is shown on the right. [ Large image ] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
A "front" view of the two boosters (the two studs
are the attachments for the master cylinder). [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
This is the '97 booster after it was returned to me from
Precision Rebuilders.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The master
cylinder and brake boosters shown in the original position (A and B) and
next to it (C), in the engine compartment of my '97 XJ w/ABS. |
The master cylinder and brake boosters shown in the original position
(A and B) and next to it (C, which is the '87 booster), in the engine compartment
of my '89 XJ. [ Large image] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
It appears that the '96 booster rod is another version that will not fit either into older XJs! Or do they? Matt Homan figured out how to make a '95/'96 booster fit without the need to swap the actuator rod! (Full report below the '96 images). '95/'96 XJs had boosters with different part numbers and different rod numbers. The rod number on this '96 booster is: 19902 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
The rod number on this '96 booster is: 19902 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Here is Matt Homan's report on how to use a '95/'96 dual-diaphragm booster without replacing the pedal rod: I was at the local Jeep only junkyard looking for something else,
when I started looking at the power boosters. I knew the later ones were
better, so I compared the '96 to an older one. The rod lengths looked
close so I measured and --bingo!-- they were exactly the same. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
I swapped in a '96 non-ABS booster (PN 52008647) into my '87 that was pretty much a bolt in. No pedal rod swap required. The distance on the old style booster from the back of the booster to the center of the hole in the rod is 4 7/8". The '96 booster (and the other years of the dual diaphragm boosters as well) use a 1/4" aluminum spacer between the back of the booster and the firewall. The distance on the ‘96 from the back of the alum. spacer to the center of the rod hole is the exact same as the earlier unit at 4 7/8". If you don't use the factory spacer, the rod will be too long. If your ‘95 has the same 4 7/8" (w/spacer) rod length, then it will work. The '97 and up rods are way to long. The dual diaphragm boosters mount at a different angle than the earlier ones, negating the need for the offset rod hole. Compare the boosters side by side and you'll see the drastic difference in the mounting angle. When installed, the rod hole lined up perfectly with the hole in the brake pedal and the pedal was at exactly the same distance from the floor as it was with the old booster. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Two minor mods were required: The diameter of the rod hole in the '96 booster is 1/2" versus 9/16" on the older ones. The bolt that goes through the pedal is 3/8", so a new 3/8" ID to 1/2" OD spacer is required to replace the original one. It cost about 59˘ at a hardware store. The brake light switch on my '87 wouldn't work so I simply used one from a '93 XJ (PN J5352620). My '87 (can't speak for other years) already had a mounting hole near the top of the pedal assembly that the '93 switch fit perfectly. The '93 switch is threaded and I just used a flat washer and nut to hold it in place. The wiring was adapted using simple male and female blade-type terminal connectors. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Big difference in stopping power and the swap can be done inexpensively if junk yard parts are used. I used the '96 master cyl. and combo valve. I didn't try to fit the old master cyl., but I don't think it would work. The area where the booster push rod engages the master is different on '96 master. Also the new booster is angled up toward the hood and the '96 master is built to account for the angle. The old master might hit the hood. The '96 combo valve works fine (I have a stock D30 and D44 with drum brakes) and since it mounts on a little bracket that attaches to the master cylinder mount, it is much easier to get to than the stock one. I just used flare unions and bent up line extensions to the new valve. You can use the stock combo valve, but you still will have to bend up new lines from the master to the combo valve. The work is probably about the same and is the most difficult part of the whole conversion. Somebody mentioned to me that the hole I used for the brake light switch was for a cruise control switch. That may be true, I don't have cruise. I don't think it would be hard to make up a bracket for the switch, though. Someone also mentioned to me that the part number of the '96 booster was discontinued. Was the part number superceded by another part number? I run into this all the time with older parts. I find it hard to believe that DaimlerChrysler would not have a replacement to sell. If it is truly discontinued, then you can get a new booster at AutoZone for $95. My washer bottle bit the dust a long time ago and the space it occupied now is home to my RS9000 controller. The washer bottle may have to be relocated or moved a bit to clear the new booster. The total cost for my conversion was about
$130. Matt Homan Thank you Matt! |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
The following images here are taken by Rob
Shelley from his '94XJ equipped with ABS (Inline-6
engine).
Shown here is a '94 XJ with a double-diaphragm booster. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Shown here from top is the '94 XJ with a double-diaphragm booster. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
This is the sticker (with part number and manufacturer) of this double-diaphragm booster. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
This is the sticker (with part number and manufacturer) of this '94 master cylinder. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Here is the pedal rod shown from inside the cab (underneath the dash).
Here is Rob's comment: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Some of the tools and parts required for this swap (with rod swap): | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Here are some of the tools shown that are required for this swap. "Common" tools, such as wrenches (SAE and metric), are not shown. A: Double-flaring tool kit (with
adapters on the right). Not shown: a brake line bending tool (not really
required if you got some feeling in your finger tips left). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Detail view of the newer style master cylinder
with the brake line adapters already installed and some adapters still
packaged (Edelmann parts). [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Detail view of the double flaring tool kit with
miscellaneous hardware. [ Large image] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Edelmann adapters (blue) with 3/16" flare nuts already in place (brass). Check your local parts store, but it must be a good one. AutoZone is not the place for that sort of "detail work". Part numbers for the (blue) adapters: These adapters are for use with the new master
cylinder. It is possible to obtain brake lines from the dealer and then
remove the flare nuts. I have not yet researched this option too much
because I personally prefer to keep standard parts whenever
possible. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Detail view of the new master cylinder with the adapters, flare nuts, and one brake line installed (for this image only.) The brake lines need to be bent first, of course. Part numbers: [ Large image] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Detail view of the new master cylinder with one
of the (blue) Edelmann adapters in place, the standard flare nut, and
a standard 3/16" brake line (which is used in all XJs, new and old
--nothing changes here.) [ Large image] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| The procedure: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| After all the parts are located (booster, master cyl., and the misc. brake line adapters, etc.) the next step is to get the pedal rods switched out. The newer pedal rods are too long (Kevin Marcus found this out the hard way!) A rebuilder shop can swap these rods out at reasonable cost. I sent my new and old boosters to Precision Rebuilders in St. Clair, MO (www.precisionrebuilders.com). After the rods are swapped, the old booster is no longer needed and can be tossed out. The new booster (now with the original pedal rod installed), can now be installed. I opted to pull another old power brake booster from a local yard ($20), which added a bit to the project cost, but allowed me to keep my '89 XJ running until I get my new booster back. If the vehicle is not needed, that little extra cost can be avoided. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Start with draining the brake fluid. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Remove the brake line fittings from the
master cylinder. It is possible that the smaller of the flare nuts might
get damaged. These brake lines are no longer needed and can be cut for
easier component removal. Keep the flare nuts! [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Master cylinder removed. |
At some point also remove the washer
fluid bottle. It adds room to work and needs to be moved forward anyway by
about 1". | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Now into the interior! The booster is mounted to the firewall with four
bolts (red arrows). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Identify the bold that hold the pedal rod to the brake pedal (red circle). Notice its position (nut on the right for Automatics, nut on the left for manuals). Remove the bolt and pull off the brake light switch. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Make sure to remember on how the brake light switch is mounted (for reassembly). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Remove the above identified booster bolts (four). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Back into the engine bay... --pull the old booster out. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Now remove the flare nut fittings from the proportioning valve (those might be tight! I clipped my old brake lines and used a deep socket to remove them without damage. Those flare nuts (1/4" thread on 3/16" pipe and 5/16" on 3/16" pipe, both steel) will both be re-used later during reassembly). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Hour of truth... how well does it fit?
(Pretty darn well --but tight!) [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Test mounting the master cylinder and washer fluid bottle (at its approximate new location). Newer XJs have the washer fluid container inside the fender. Probably for a good reason! | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Now the tricky part begins: Making (i.e. bending) the new custom brake lines. This was by far the most time consuming part of this project. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Another view with the mock (wire) lines in place. These are the samples for the real lines. The rear line needs a tight bend away from the booster (towards engine) and then immediately around the electrical connector that sits between the two lines on the proportioning valve. Newer XJs (such as my '97 XJ) have the
proportioning valve mounted on a little bracket that is bolted to the
booster. That might be an alternative method, but then custom extension
must be made to relocate the proportioning valve (which is at least as
much of a hassle than the tight custom lines). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
It took some effort, but in the end these lines had something of a "professional" look to them. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Remove the booster and install the lines at their final postion.
Tighten the flare nuts well (these are steel ones that are for the
proportioning valve.) [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Now install the booster, --make sure you keep all the lines for the washer
fluid bottle accessible. Install the new master cylinder and attach the
brake lines to the Edelmann adapters. [ Large image ] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
It is a tight fit. Especially the rear line is a tough one. It almost collides with the new booster, but with some trick-bending, it will eventually clear. Also, the washer fluid bottle must be moved forward. Redrill the three holes and bolt it back down. In the end all worked fine and even looks very neat. Fill the system with brake fluid and bleed the brakes. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Some additional images of a converted '96 power brake booster installed in an early V6 XJ: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Here the '96 booster installed after it was
converted to the earlier pedal rod by Precision
Rebuilders. The '96 booster is not a direct swap. The pedal rod needs
to be replaced like all other newer double-diaphragm brake boosters out of
XJs or ZJs. The engine bay of the '84 to '86 XJs/MJs provides more room to route the hard lines. Compare the following images with the ones taken from the '89 XJ with the inline-6 and it becomes evident that there are two major differences: a) in the early XJs there is no washer fluid container next to the brake booster, and b) there is also more room between the engine block and the booster/master cylinder. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
With the added room in the engine bay, the custom
bending of the hard lines (new master cylinder to proportioning
valve) is easier.
It is still a tight fit between the new booster and the rear line coming out of
the proportioning valve, but at least there is the added room to the engine and
no washer fluid bottle that needs to be cleared. Since this was my second set of
these lines, this time it was noticeably faster and easier to make them. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Another image showing the new master cylinder, the '96 booster, and the custom brake lines.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
The pedal rod (actuator rod) was also swapped out by Precision Rebuilders with same-day
turn-around. Waiting for the booster rebuild was essentially only the time it took for
shipping it to Precision Rebuilders and back. Also notice the adapters on the new master cylinder. These adapters are the same as used above on the '89 booster swap (same part numbers, etc.). [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
This image is maybe a bit confusing at first. This
view is
directly from top straight down onto the proportioning valve. It shows the critical bend first away
from the booster (this is the tightest bend) and then immediately around the proportioning valve
switch. The second custom hard line (hier on the left) is much easier. [Large image] |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Summary: Not exactly a direct swap, but it is not very difficult to do with the right preparation. The pedal rod swap tip by Kevin Marcus proved to be a very crucial one! The most time-consuming part was making the custom brake lines. The Edelmann adapters were of great help! This upgrade works excellent and provides great
results with a properly working brake system. Obviously, it does not fix
problems that are elsewhere in the complex brake system.
It is important that all brake components are in
good shape and the system is well bled, otherwise this upgrade
will achieve little! |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
All Rights reserved. Photos: Andreas Ritterbusch |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
[MADXJ]